Manny Machado or Jonathan Schoop?

Manny Machado and Jonathan Schoop jog in Spring Training.
GulfBird Sports/Craig Landefeld

The hot stove has been heating up the past couple of weeks with some minor O’s chatter about the likes of Jason Vargas, Tyler Chatwood and Andrew Cashner. Those acquisitions would do very little to help the O’s World Series odds at the best sports betting sites, and are mere peanuts compared to the pending expiring contracts that the Orioles are facing from within; Manny Machado, Zach Britton and Adam Jones are all set to be UFA at the conclusion of the 2018 season, with Jonathan Schoop following just behind at the conclusion of 2019. The popular opinion around town has been to lock up Schoop now, and let Manny walk due to the presumed outrageous numbers he would command.

So whom should the Orioles invest their money in, Machado or Schoop?

Jonathan Schoop vs Manny Machado

Both! They should invest in both.

The Orioles have a rare opportunity to build around two superstars – one established and one budding, and both set to enter the prime of their careers – and to let this chance pass them by would be criminal.

Consider what we have seen.  Schoop spent the majority of 2017 batting right in front of or behind Machado for the first time in his career. The result?  His best season by far, .293/.338/.503 slash line with 32 HR, 105 RBI, and 182 hits. Don’t think for a second that his position next to Machado in the lineup is not directly correlated to these MVP-ish (he finished 12th in the voting) numbers.

Further, those of us who drink the orange kool-aid have every reason to believe Schoop will sustain his improvement, all while Machado rebounds from a disappointing offensive 2017 in which his slash line dipped to career lows at .259/.310/.471. Despite that however, he still provided power with 33 HR and 95 RBI, and was much improved from the first half to the second.

Let’s take a step back for a moment and think about this logically. The Orioles have two players who have come up through their system together, are young, and happen to be the very best of friends. Could you ask for a better PR marketing scenario? OH and by the way, they’re both All Stars who bat in the middle of your lineup and you can build around for the next 5-7 years.

How can you pass this opportunity up?


Coming off the books this offseason is approximately $51 million from Ubaldo Jimenez, Chris Tillman, Wade Miley, Seth Smith, Welington Castillo, Hyun Soo Kim and Ryan “The GOAT” Flaherty. $50 million split between them (say, ~$30M/yr for Machado and ~$20M/yr for Schoop) should be enough to get the job done.

Payroll will go up; that’s unavoidable. But it’s time for the Orioles, as an organization, to stop pretending they want to win a World Series and go out and do it. For the first time in recent memory, the O’s cracked the top 10 in 2017 MLB payroll, coming in at number 10 (largely due to arbitration numbers and a phenomenal contract for Chris Davis).

Guess what? That’s not good enough when the top 5 is made up of 3/5 of your own division (Yankees, Red Sox and Jays).  The whole point of player development and organizational success is to acquire guys like Machado and Schoop.

Now that we have them, we can’t let them go.

2 Cheers on “Manny Machado or Jonathan Schoop?

  1. avatarD'andre on said:

    They just bet against themselves and signed Davis to 171-m, trumo to a big contract. now you want to spend 50-m a year on schoop and machado? no way. Logically this team even with those two is the same, no pitching and a farm system that historically sucks. this team needs to rebuild. sign schoop yes ofr aroun 15-20 then trade machado for pitching, the problem is they new they couldn’t afford machado for the last 2 years now, they could’ve gotten someone’s first born for him, Now the value is diminished unless you wait until the break when a team needs someone to help them over the hump but thh orioles front office always misses the boat. I’d even say let’s give britton a chance back in the rotation, he’a little older now and that sinker can keep him out of trouble in Camden yards

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.

Hot off the street

Friday’s O’s Links: Dylan Bundy to Make First Opening Day Start
Friday’s O’s Links: Dylan Bundy to Make First Opening Day Start

The snow has already completely cleared from the ground in most parts of Baltimore, a fitting sight as we sit now less than a week from Opening Day. Now let's push that mercury a bit further up, eh more

Thursday Thoughts: Prediction Time
Thursday Thoughts: Prediction Time

This is a weekly column that dives into some random thoughts about the Orioles/MLB. I used to do eight as a nod to Cal Ripken Jr. As of last year, I cut it down to four or five, so consider it the more

Orioles Starting Rotation Comes Into Focus
Orioles Starting Rotation Comes Into Focus

Over the last week or so, this column has been dedicated to answering some of the roster questions the Orioles still have as Opening Day draws near. Having already discussed the outfield and the more

Orioles Get their Man in Alex Cobb
Orioles Get their Man in Alex Cobb

In this space three weeks ago, I condemned the Orioles for their lack of moves to make the team a legitimate contender entering 2018. I criticized the outfield situation, namely the signing of Colby more

Wednesday’s O’s Links: Hi, Alex!
Wednesday’s O’s Links: Hi, Alex!

While we were all scrambling to stock up on our bread, milk, and toilet paper yesterday evening, the Orioles were finalizing discussions with Alex Cobb to bring the free agent pitcher to Baltimore. more

View More