Subscribe to our newsletter

Welington Castillo Catching On or Catching Up?

Welington Castillo
Share on facebook
Share on twitter
Share on pinterest
Share on email
Print Friendly, PDF & Email
Reading Time: 3 minutes

Orioles fans, and to some extent, the media members who cover them, are up in arms over new catcher Welington Castillo’s decision to play for his native Dominican Republic’s team in this month’s World Baseball Classic. He’ll leave camp this weekend to report to his country’s squad.

The international tournament blows a huge crater into his first spring training session with the Orioles – his first real opportunity to become acclimated with a new-to-him pitching staff, fellow catchers on the team, coaches and especially manager Buck Showalter.

Minus the appearance of just six games with Seattle in 2015 — when he was traded to the Mariners and away from them in separate transactions 15 days apart — Castillo has been a National League lifer, splitting his previous seven seasons between the Cubs and Diamondbacks.

To complicate matters, this is also pitching coach Roger McDowell’s first season with the Orioles, turning the page on an 11-season stint as pitching coach with the Atlanta Braves. An opportunity to work with the team’s projected No. 1 catcher more often before Opening Day on April 3 would be a welcome one.

But how big of a deal is it, really?

Jack McDowell (no relation to the current pitching coach), who won the 1993 American League Cy Young Award with the White Sox, said in a Facebook message that he believes Castillo will be fine, and other catchers have had to adjust to new teams with shorter notice.

“What if he got traded to the team in May?” the three-time All-Star and two-time 20-game winner asked. “These are big league guys, the adjustments are quick.”

Former catcher Gregg Zaun, who played 16 seasons in the Major Leagues — including three seasons in two stops with the Orioles — will get a look at Castillo on April 3 when Baltimore hosts Toronto in both teams’ season opener. Zaun is a studio host — much like his uncle Rick Dempsey is for the Orioles’ MASN — for the Toronto Blue Jays, a team he played five seasons for.

In all, Zaun played for nine franchises, so he knows a little something about being a catcher who’s been asked to learn new staffs on the fly.

“I would want to spend as much time with the guys as I could prior to the beginning of a season when joining a new team,” Zaun said in an e-mail. “That being said, I played in an era that was prior to the enormous amount of scouting and information that’s out there now. I relied on my eyes and my experience to guide me through calling a game. I forged relationships during spring training that served me well in the heat of the battle.”

But he admits that today’s game is one of a different attitude than from his era, for better or for worse.

“Things have changed in the game a little — you have rookie pitchers shaking off veteran catchers left and right in their Major League debuts,” he said. “Long gone are the days of following your catcher blindly through a ball game, and rightfully so. Many of them are terrible game callers and oblivious to reading bats.”

Zaun, however, said he thinks the Orioles and Castillio should to be able to work through his limited availability in spring training.

“It would’ve been a nice gesture for Castillo to forgo the WBC in lieu of joining a new team, but I think he will have plenty of time to get to know his teammates. As far as game-calling and knowing the strengths and weaknesses of his pitching staff go … that’s common knowledge.

“Pitchers are creatures of habit. When their backs are against the wall, they are going to do what they’ve always done. Chances are if Welington Castillo cares one iota about calling a good game, he already knows what his guys are going to do. He would have seen that from afar as a student of the game while casually watching baseball games.”

As far as the World Baseball Classic goes, Zaun belongs to the camp that thinks the international tournament might be more trouble than it’s worth. Participating players — and Orioles’ front-line players Adam Jones, Manny Machado, Jonathan Schoop and Mychal Givens are also playing in the WBC — risk injuries that could keep them from being available to their respective Major League Baseball teams who are paying them millions of dollars.

“If people are making a big deal out of his participation in the WBC, they should probably take a look at the participation of other players as well,” he said. “The WBC, while a good idea in theory, is an unneeded distraction for players and certainly a risky and dangerous situation for all who participate. They are not in good enough shape to be playing highly competitive baseball at this point in the calendar. Most players are barely ready for it Opening Day.

“Major League Baseball should rethink the WBC right after they rethink how they decide home field advantage in the World Series.”

0 Responses

  1. This is a really good article, Kevin, with lots of insight from people in the know. I haven’t seen a better analysis anywhere. Thanks!

Coby Mayo
News and Analysis

High Schoolers in the Draft? It’s Worked for O’s So Far…

With the MLB Draft about three weeks away, the excitement around it has started to rise. Mock Drafts are everywhere across the internet; analysts and …

Read More →
Down on the Farm

Huge Moments Highlight O’s Win in Sarasota

Some recent international signings are paying off for the Orioles and on Tuesday they contributed to a team win marked by several significant firsts. RHP …

Read More →
Adley Rutschman home run chain
News and Analysis

Not Satisfied with “Fun,” Orioles are Approaching “Good”

It’s now been over a month since I wrote about how the 2022 Baltimore Orioles threw a plot twist at us on their way to …

Read More →
De Los Santos
Down on the Farm

Anderson De Los Santos – A Closer Look

As he’s coming into his own as a rookie leaguer, Orioles corner prospect Anderson De Los Santos is showing what kind of player he’ll be …

Read More →
men sitting at draft tables in large open room decorated with sports stuff
News and Analysis

Identifying Potential Over-Slot Options

In last week’s article, I mentioned how the advantage of “going under slot” is the ability to get more young talent in a farm system …

Read More →
Jorge Lopez
News and Analysis

The Poor Man’s Britton: Should O’s Consider Dealing Jorge Lopez?

Jorge Lopez is in the middle of an excellent season. He was a player that the Orioles kept in the rotation far too long but …

Read More →
Get notified of the Latest Sport News Update from Our Blog
Latest posts
Join our newsletter and get 20% discount
Promotion nulla vitae elit libero a pharetra augue