Would You Trade Places with the Astros?

The Houston Astros and Baltimore Orioles couldn’t be more different. Both are major league baseball franchises, and up until very recently, that’s about where the similarities ended. The Astros have appeared in two of the last three World Series, winning one (in 2017), and losing another in seven games (last year, to the Washington Nationals). The Orioles, of course, haven’t appeared in a Fall Classic since 1983.

Houston has won an average of 96 games per season over the past five years, topping 100 each of the last three. The O’s, meanwhile, have lost 100+ games in two straight seasons, and haven’t played in a playoff series since 2014 (they played in the Wild Card game in 2016). The Astros have been on the cutting edge of the baseball analytics revolution, putting together a front office that was the envy of the rest of the league. The Orioles, until hiring Mike Elias & Sig Mejdal away from said Astros just over a year ago, were the laughingstock of baseball in this regard, barely having an analytics department at all.

So, it would seem a no-brainer that Orioles fans would have been happy to trade places with Astros fans here over the last half-decade or so. We’d have jumped at the chance.

However, all of that changed recently, with the Astros being found guilty of using technology to steal signs during their recent run of success. The ‘Stros were fined $5 million; their manager, A.J. Hinch, and GM, Jeff Luhnow, were both suspended for the entire 2020 season (and subsequently fired by the team); they were stripped of their 2020 and 2021 first-round draft picks; Alex Cora and Carlos Beltran, members of Houston in 2017, both lost their jobs, as manager of the Boston Red Sox and New York Mets, respectively.

As a result of all this, Houston’s entire legacy is in question.

It’s a brutal episode for MLB, and for baseball fans everywhere, regardless of whether you cheer for the Astros, feel that your team was wronged by them on their way to all those wins, or just love the game in general. It’s the steroid scandal all over again, in some ways.

That black cloud that will hang over baseball will be explored exhaustively over the next few weeks, months, and years. What I was curious about, was whether or not Birdland would still trade places with Houston, given the chance.

My informal Twitter poll, that got 516 votes (presumably near all from O’s fans) found that 41% of O’s fans would still trade places. Here’s a sampling of some of the responses folks wrote:

Honestly, the voting went about as I’d expected. It’s a tough question, and I’m fascinated by the responses, on both sides. I think that, if you asked fans of a team that hasn’t been as long-suffering as we O’s fans have, you’d get a lot more people saying “No!” They don’t know the struggle, man.

I should also point out that I took the poll before the most recent allegations, that players actually had buzzers taped to their bodies to alert them what pitch was coming. Would that affect the results, I wonder?

So what about you? If a fairy could wave a magic wand and make the 2015-2019 Orioles and Astros trade places – the good and the bad – would you sign up for that?

This entry was posted in Bird Feed, Blog View, Featured by Derek Arnold. Bookmark the permalink.

About Derek Arnold

RSR/ESR Senior Editor. Derek is originally from and a current resident of Pasadena, MD. He’s a graduate of UMBC and has been a lifelong Baltimore sports fan. In 2007 he founded B’More Birds’ Nest, where he wrote about the Ravens and Orioles before joining RSR in 2012. Derek tells anyone...more

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.

Hot off the street

The Payoff Pitch: Show Me The Baseball!
The Payoff Pitch: Show Me The Baseball!

In this week's episode of The Payoff Pitch, I go over the Orioles' truncated 60-game schedule, wonder why a couple Orioles haven't been seen on the field yet, and tear into the Mid-Atlantic Sports Net...read more

The Payoff Pitch: Baseball is…Back?!
The Payoff Pitch: Baseball is…Back?!

Two weeks, two installments of The Payoff Pitch! It seems Major League Baseball and the Players Union got their heads out of their own posteriors long enough to reach an agreement on a 60 game season ...read more

Baseball’s Back…But At What Cost?
Baseball’s Back…But At What Cost?

It's been a hell of a few months for all of us, not just as Orioles fans or even as baseball fans, but as humanity. The world has been turned upside down by a global pandemic, and the baseball world i...read more

The Payoff Pitch: 2020 MLB Draft Recap
The Payoff Pitch: 2020 MLB Draft Recap

We're back! Hopefully MLB will follow shortly...why don't they already have a plan in place? Well, let's spend a few minutes talking about why Rob Manfred is the worst thing to happen to Major League ...read more

O’s Look to Get Armed in Undrafted Signing Period
O’s Look to Get Armed in Undrafted Signing Period

While the fact that the 2020 MLB Draft was a shortened version of normal certainly isn’t ideal for a rebuilding team such as the Orioles, it does afford them a unique opportunity in the undrafted fr...read more

View More