Four Potential Trades to Boost the O’s Rotation

Julio Teheran of the Braves pitches from the mound.

It’s exciting to see that the Orioles are continuing to hold off the Red Sox and Blue Jays in first place because of their powerful lineup. Basically every hitter on the team presents a threat to opposing pitchers. While they are currently third in the AL in runs per game at 4.81 (trailing Seattle and Boston), they still have what I consider to be the most dangerous lineup in the game.

It’s hard to imagine the team staying in first place though if they don’t trade for another arm or two in the rotation. Chris Tillman has been the only consistent starter for Baltimore and considering Kevin Gausman‘s struggles and depending on how much Yovani Gallardo helps, solidifying the rotation is priority number one as the trade deadline approaches.

The biggest issue with making a trade is that the Orioles’ farm system is dried up and there aren’t many trade-able pieces – without completely emptying the cupboard. However, there are a few ways the team could make a deal. Let’s think about some of them.

Orioles Receive: P Rich Hill

Athletics Receive: 1B Christian Walker, P Tanner Scott

Rich Hill refuses to fail in the MLB and has already put together a great season with an 8-3 record and 2.25 ERA. He’s holding batters to an abysmal .207 batting average and deserves to be on a contender. He is currently on the DL, but will hopefully be back in action soon.

Billy Beane loves to wheel-and-deal and knows he can get a decent haul for the 36-year-old pitcher. However, not many teams will go over the top for a player at the back end of his career. That means the Moneyball guru might have to settle for less than he’d hope to get for a younger pitcher.

Walker has nowhere to go in Baltimore after the team locked up Chris Davis. He is playing outfield in Norfolk, but there is a logjam there, too. He would have a chance to start right away – at his natural position – with the A’s, as Yonder Alonso is a short-term solution at first base.

Scott would be the biggest chip though, as the hard-throwing lefty has held opponents to a .107 batting average this season. He won’t be ready for a couple of years and would be a good investment for Oakland.

It could be a steep price for Baltimore to pay, as they’ve parted with Zach Davies and Josh Hader in the recent past, but Hill would help the team contend for the AL East Title.

Orioles Receive: P Drew Pomeranz

Padres Receive: P Tanner Scott, P David Hess, 1B Christian Walker

Pomeranz has gone under the radar this year, but has a 3.00 ERA and 96 strikeouts. The Padres are looking to sell after unloading James Shields and would likely move Pomeranz if the deal was right.

He won’t come cheap since he has arbitration years remaining and is starting to come into his own as pitcher. The Orioles would have to give up the same type of haul they offer for Hill and then add another pitcher.

It’s a deal that could work out for both sides if Pomeranz turns into a No. 3 arm for the Orioles and the Padres are able to develop both pitchers. Yes, I’m also adding Walker in every deal I’ve mentioned. Some team will like him.

Orioles Receive: P Julio Teheran

Braves Receive: SS Ryan Mountcastle, P Tanner Scott, P David Hess, C Jonah Heim

Now this would definitely make you drop your phone if you saw something like this happen. Teheran is stuck on a team with a terrible offense, which explains his 3-7 record. However, he boasts a 2.66 ERA and 3.34 career ERA, which makes him very attractive to the Orioles.

He’ll be as expensive as Matt Harvey (yes, I said Matt Harvey – see below), but in a different way. The Braves need to start over and the Orioles will have to offer some of their best prospects in order to get a deal done. I’d imagine the Braves would start talks around Mountcastle and Scott, considering they need a future shortstop and pitching help. Hess and Heim would be sweeteners and adding them might get a deal done.

Teheran would instantly become the team’s No. 2 starter and would be under control until 2019. It’s a lot to give up, but would help the team contend for the next couple years.

Orioles Receive: P Matt Harvey

Mets Receive: 1B/OF Mark Trumbo, 1B Christian Walker, P David Hess

This scenario is at the end of my list because it seems to be the least likely, but the idea is quite interesting to me, so let’s talk about it. The Mets are in trouble and need to make a big move to fix their lineup in order to keep in the Wild Card Race. Insert Mark Trumbo.

[Related: Orioles Should Trade Mark Trumbo in July]

It’s no secret that a) the Orioles will have trouble keeping Trumbo in Baltimore next season; and b) should explore a trade for a pitcher. The Mets have a plethora of starters and the front office has started to sour on Harvey. He’s had a non-Harvey season so far as well, which might convince the team to pull the trigger.

Walker and Hess should be sufficient enough as a package with Trumbo. New York might want Trey Mancini instead, but I don’t see Baltimore being willing to move him.

Which pitcher would you like the Orioles to trade for?

Of course, I have to admit that it’s unlikely that either of my final two proposals would even be a consideration for the Orioles. We’ve seen enough of Dan Duquette by now to know how he operates. If anything, expect another Bud Norris or Scott Feldman-type move in July.

But hey, it’s still fun to dream about Teheran or Harvey in black and orange.

3 Cheers on “Four Potential Trades to Boost the O’s Rotation

  1. avatarTyler Rauhauser on said:

    I like the different possibilities you have explored here. My concern with your analysis of the Teheran trade possibility is that you mention Mountcastle as part of the deal because, “I’d imagine the Braves would start talks around Mountcastle and Scott, considering they need a future shortstop …” when the Braves system boasts two shortstop prospects in Dansby Swanson(#6) and Ozzie Albeis(#25) who rank in the top 25 prospects according to’s top 100 prospects. ( Swanson is currently playing at the AA level and Albeis is at the AAA level of the Braves’ system. Who else would you think the Braves would be interested in as a position player? Maybe, Christian Walker or DJ Stewart? Walker would likely have a chance to compete for a regular role as a corner outfielder with the Braves as they open their new stadium next season. Stewart is still a couple of seasons away but with the “log-jam” in Baltimore at 1B and OF, he becomes expendable, no? Thanks for your thoughts!

  2. avatarB Up 22 on said:

    I’m thinking once Hunter Harvey makes it back and gets a couple starts under his belt (he’s had leg injuries not arm issues recently)…. a package of Hunter Harvey, Tanner Scott, Drew Dosch (or Josh Hart depending on if the braves need INF or OF prospects), and Johan Heim

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.

Hot off the street

Playing the Slots with MLB Draft Picks
Playing the Slots with MLB Draft Picks

Adley Rutschman still hasn’t signed, which could be causing some apprehension in Birdland. The reality is, Rutschman is signing. For how much of a signing bonus has yet to be determined, but it more

Hanser Alberto is the Answer at Leadoff Hitter for O’s
Hanser Alberto is the Answer at Leadoff Hitter for O’s

Leadoff hitter has been a massive position of need for the Baltimore Orioles since the departure of Brian Roberts. They’ve fiddled with the role, finding waiver wire pickups, drafting Rule-5 more

Sunny and Hot for O’s-Red Sox
Sunny and Hot for O’s-Red Sox

The weather will be quite pleasant for the opening game and middle game of the Red Sox weekend series with Friday evening’s game featuring very comfortable temperatures. We’ll warm up a bit more

Time for Bruce Zimmermann to Get the Call
Time for Bruce Zimmermann to Get the Call

Griesser's Suggested Change of the Week With the sheer volume of games in an MLB season, it’s inevitable that teams need to change things up on a regular basis. In fact, for an organization that’ more

Payoff Pitch Prospect Report: Rom Rising
Payoff Pitch Prospect Report: Rom Rising

In this edition of The Payoff Pitch Prospect Report, Paul updates Baltimore Orioles fans on the latest from down on the farm, where Delmarva Shorebirds pitcher Drew Rom is turning heads. Elsewhere, more

View More