Who Will Make Up the O’s “Starting Five?”

Before the first game of the Spring Training season gets underway on Saturday, I think a fun experiment would be a sort of projection for the Orioles’ biggest question mark this year: the rotation. In this article, I will outline the players I feel will crack the Opening Day roster as the prototypical ‘starting five’ (yes, for the purpose of the piece I will assume that Brandon Hyde won’t use openers at the onset of the season).

There are a lot of holes in the rotation this year, and that’s seemed to be the case for the past decade or longer. If this rebuild is going to work, those holes will have to be filled. This year, General Manager Mike Elias has gathered a variety of candidates, prospects and veterans alike. I withhold all right to change my opinions at the end of Spring Training, but here’s how I believe it will shake out right now:

John Means

There’s not too much to write about here. John Means is coming off an incredible rookie season with Baltimore, becoming the team’s ace and All-Star representative. I do believe there’s room for an unfortunate drop-off, but either way, he will enter the season as the team’s Opening Day starter.


Alex Cobb

For me, Alex Cobb is actually the biggest question mark for the Orioles this year. He could bounce back and have a healthy, strong 2020 – in which case he’ll be traded. Or, he could fall off a cliff again and stink up the joint – in which case he should be designated for assignment and replaced with a prospect. Regardless, Elias will be sure to see what he has in Cobb from the start.


Kohl Stewart

In all honesty, I don’t know this Kohl Stewart guy whatsoever, so I’m excited to see what he does in Sarasota. At the same time, the Orioles invested in him to a certain degree, probably slightly more than most of their signings this offseason. With that in mind, I think he’ll slot in behind Means and Cobb in the Opening Day rotation.

[Related: Be Excited About the O’s Young Pitching]


Wade LeBlanc

This is where things get really interesting in terms of the names involved. The final two spots of the rotation could be a competition between the likes of Wade LeBlanc, David Hess, Keegan Akin, and the Rule 5 Selections, among others. With the most experience and a left-handed arm, I believe LeBlanc makes it out of camp alive.


Michael Rucker

Finding himself in a competition with fellow Rule-5 Selection Brandon Bailey, I feel Michael Rucker is better prepared to break camp with the team. Elias should be compelled to keep at least one of these names until they completely prove themselves incapable of finding success at the Major League level. To that point, I believe one of them will travel back to Baltimore with the team, and considering the need at the back-end of the rotation, it’ll be Rucker.

You might be asking, “Hey Aidan, what about Woj-Bomb?” Well, reader, trust me when I say he’s still relevant, and I haven’t forgotten my excitement for his success. He’ll be in the bullpen and – especially if Hyde brings out openers – he’ll start numerous games on the bump for the O’s in 2020.

Let me know what you think in the comments section or on Twitter (@aidan_griesser). I can’t wait for Saturday.

This entry was posted in Bird Feed, Blog View, Featured by Aidan Griesser. Bookmark the permalink.

About Aidan Griesser

Aidan Griesser is a student at Boston College but don't worry, the evil influence of Boston sports can't sway his devotion to the Baltimore Ravens and Orioles! Aidan's from Annapolis and previously worked with the B-More Opinionated podcast for two years. When it comes to sports writing, Aidan is interested...more

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.

Hot off the street

COVID-19 Crisis and MLB: An Opportunity Amidst Tragedy?
COVID-19 Crisis and MLB: An Opportunity Amidst Tragedy?

Disclaimer: Just as I did when writing about this topic on Russell Street Report, I need to state that sports are absolutely secondary/tertiary/etc. in the grand scheme of things, and that's especiall...read more

O’s Pitcher Suggests to MLB, “Let’s Play it Safe!”
O’s Pitcher Suggests to MLB, “Let’s Play it Safe!”

On March 12, the Orioles had literally to turn around while already on the bus to go to Fort Myers for a spring training game, and go back to the Ed Smith Stadium complex. That was the moment Major Le...read more

Once Upon a Time…When “Orioles” Meant Football Too
Once Upon a Time…When “Orioles” Meant Football Too

In the beginning was baseball. Did you know that the first American League of Professional Football in the United States was created by... the owners of the National League of Professional Baseball Cl...read more

O’s & Mets to Play at Naval Academy on March 24
O’s & Mets to Play at Naval Academy on March 24

It's show time! Get ready for the exhibition game between the Baltimore Orioles and New York Mets  The date is March 24 at 2:05 p.m. ET, the venue is the campus of the Naval Academy, more precisel...read more

Hanser Alberto Cannot Surprise Me in 2020
Hanser Alberto Cannot Surprise Me in 2020

During this time last year, most people didn’t have infielder Hanser Alberto breaking camp with the Orioles. I include myself among that list. But keeping him turned out to be a great decision by th...read more

View More