Hot Take Tuesday: Means’ Season O’s Best Since Bedard

In a frustrating 2019 campaign, the first year of a long rebuild that the Orioles are undergoing, it’s critical for fans to follow the exciting stories. They’re few and far between, that’s for sure, but it’s on us to enjoy them when we see them.

To that point, there’s no easier story to enjoy than the emergence of John Means, the Orioles’ new ace.

As the O’s All-Star representative, Means has quickly become a fan favorite and a household name in Baltimore. That’s impressive, especially given the fact that he’s a rookie on the league’s worst team.

But while we all know Means has been good this year, I don’t think enough people are talking about how good he’s been.

For as long as I can remember, Baltimore has been complaining about the genuine lack of top-of-the-rotation arms on the Orioles roster. This year, we’ve got that.

In realizing that, I took a look at how Means’ season stacks up against those of some past players, and my resulting take is steaming: John Means is having the best season on the mound since Erik Bedard’s 2007 campaign.

To this point, John Means has pitched to a 7-4 record and a 2.50 ERA, a number that would be 2nd in the American League had he pitched a few more innings. Twelve years ago in 2007, Bedard finished 13-5 with a 3.16 ERA, obviously an extremely strong season.

Of course, Means is technically on track to finish with a better ERA, but I’m holding the belief that his ERA may balloon a bit with one or two uncharacteristically poor outings down the road. If that happens, these two guys will end up with very similar seasons by those metrics.

Digging into some more analytical results, it’s noteworthy that Bedard sported a 3.88 K/BB ratio, finishing with an impressive 221 strikeouts in 182 innings pitched. This is where Bedard definitely has a statistical advantage over Means, who thus far has 69 punchouts in 82.2 innings. At the same time, these guys are two are pretty different pitchers, with Means pitching to contact more than not.

The last metric I’ll use to compare these two seasons is WHIP, because these results are uncanny. While Bedard finished 2007 with a clean 1.09 WHIP, John Means is sitting pretty with a 1.08 WHIP to this point.

For me, this statistic is extremely important, as it shows how dominant and consistent a pitcher is. In both of these seasons, the man on the mound was or is a model of consistency.

There are a few potential rebuttals to my take that I want to review, all of which were in that window of Orioles success that we miss so deeply today.

First, Chris Tillman posted a 2.93 ERA in 2012 while making 15 starts. This definitely is a strong year, especially considering his 1.04 WHIP, but Tillman only threw 86 innings, which is essentially where Means sits so far.

Unless Means blows up in his next start, he’ll have posted a better ERA in more innings, so his season should be compared to bigger and better ones than Tillman’s 2012 year.

Next, in the same 2012 year that saw the O’s return to relevance, Miguel Gonzalez provided yearlong stability while pitching to a 9-4 record in 18 games. While three of these appearances were out of the pen, Gonzalez finished with a 3.25 ERA in 105.1 innings.

Again, Gonzalez didn’t start for a full season, which is what Means will be hoping to do. On top of that, however, Means’ ERA and WHIP could be significantly better than those with which Gonzalez finished, so his year has been more impressive.

Third, moving forward to 2014 when the birds were a legitimate contender, Gonzalez doubled down on his 2012 performance and put up a 10-9 record with a 3.23 ERA in 26 starts, a full year’s work.

Even still, Means should be in a position to maintain a better ERA, and that alone may make his season better. Furthermore, however, Gonzalez’s WHIP in 2014 was 1.29, a number much higher than the one Means will post if he stays steady on the bump.

Finally, sticking with 2014, I think it’s worth looking at the man who was viewed as the Orioles’ ace: Wei-Yin Chen. In my opinion, this is actually the best case against John Means’ 2019 campaign being the strongest since that of 2007 Bedard, as Chen was consistently relied upon and would come through regularly.

Finishing 16-6, it felt like each time Chen took the mound, the Orioles were set for a win, and more times than not, that was the case. Chen was the stopper in his strongest year, and I’d say that’s what Means has been, if you can have a stopper on a downright awful team.

What makes Means’ year better comes down to sheer statistics, though, as his are far more impressive at a glance than those Chen posted. With a 3.54 ERA and a 1.23 WHIP, Chen’s year doesn’t appear to have been nearly as good as the one Means is working toward nor the one Bedard completed.

At the same time, I think we’d all give up both Bedard’s and Means’ individual seasons combined to have a few more of the competitive team seasons like that 2012 campaign.

Here’s to seeing some that are similar in a few years, with John Means leading the way.

This entry was posted in Bird Feed, Blog View, Featured by Aidan Griesser. Bookmark the permalink.

About Aidan Griesser

Aidan Griesser
Aidan Griesser is a student at Boston College but don't worry, the evil influence of Boston sports can't sway his devotion to the Baltimore Ravens and Orioles! Aidan's from Annapolis and previously worked with the B-More Opinionated podcast for two years. When it comes to sports writing, Aidan is interested...more

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.

Hot off the street

The Payoff Pitch: Restless & FanFest-less w/Jon Meoli
The Payoff Pitch: Restless & FanFest-less w/Jon Meoli

In this offseason edition of The Payoff Pitch, I congratulate the team down 95 on their World Series win, goes over the Orioles' moves to date, and previews the owners meetings. The Baltimore Sun's O' more

Can a Poker Mindset Help the O’s Stay Focused?
Can a Poker Mindset Help the O’s Stay Focused?

Mancini’s second season saw him lose focus Photo credit: Flickr / CC BY-SA 2.0 Now, you may think that this sounds a bit odd and, truth be told, we completely understand why. How on earth can more

Learning Experience for “Fall Stars” Kremer & McCoy
Learning Experience for “Fall Stars” Kremer & McCoy

After strong starts to the Arizona Fall League season, RHP Dean Kremer and INF Mason McCoy have been selected to represent the Baltimore Orioles at this year’s Fall Stars Game. McCoy, the more

An Offseason Blueprint for the Birds
An Offseason Blueprint for the Birds

Griesser's Suggested Changes of the Offseason Finally, after a long hiatus, I’m back with a brand new installment of my Suggested Change of the Week, and considering the 54-108 record that the more

The Payoff Pitch – That’s a Wrap w/Dan Connolly
The Payoff Pitch – That’s a Wrap w/Dan Connolly

In the final episode of the 2019 season, I am joined by Dan Connolly of The Athletic to put a bow on the Baltimore Orioles' 2019 campaign. Which players made a case to be back in 2020? Who will be more

View More