Chris Davis Deal Will Set Orioles Back For Years

The Orioles re-signing of Chris Davis was a commitment to winning. It was a signal to the fans that Peter Angelos is willing to make a major investment to improve the ball club. It was a sign of hope.

Unfortunately it’s false hope.

The Orioles successfully bid against themselves and landed a player who will do nothing to make the team better than they were in 2015. It will be more of the same old, same old.

And in the end Davis’ 7 year, $161M deal will in the not-to-distant future represent a noose around the collective neck of Dan Duquette, Buck Showalter & Co.

Yes I get that $42M of the deal is deferred and that the optimist will suggest that such a deferral will allow the team to make more moves.

Are you sure?

This is Peter Angelos we are talking about.

Maybe the deferred structure is the only one that Pete would sign off on.

But that aside, $161M later have the Orioles improved?

Most would agree that the primary goal of the offseason was to improve pitching and team speed. After all the Orioles for years have been a very one-dimensional team that is heavily dependent upon long flies to be successful. They don’t steal, advance runners or even remotely play small ball.

And their formula for winning fails when it counts the most in October.

[COUNTERPOINT: Davis is Right Player at Right Price for Orioles]

When the colder weather sets in and the ball doesn’t fly as far through the autumn air; when the pitching is more intense; when the best teams in baseball compress their rotation to their top three starters; when teams’ scouting reports are as thorough as ever, detailing the weaknesses of opponents – exposing the holes in Chris Davis’ swing.

It’s then that the Orioles will be reminded of their bad investment in Davis.


There’s little doubt that when he heats up Davis can carry a club. Yet you have to wonder if the Orioles are paying Davis for what he’s done and not what we can expect from him going forward.

When the Orioles take the field in April Davis will be 30 years old. He’ll be 37 when the contract concludes. Is it reasonable to expect Davis to produce like he did in 2013 and 2015 throughout the duration of his contract? And even if he does it doesn’t necessarily translate into team wins. When he hit 53 bombs in 2013 the Orioles finished 3rd. Last season when he went yard 47 times they finished at .500.

But when Davis struggled in 2014 finishing with a .196 batting average, 26 home runs and 72 RBI, AND on the shelf from mid-September through the balance of the season due to a 25-game suspension stemming from the improper use of Adderall, the Orioles had their best season since 1997, winning the AL East with 96 wins and advancing to the ALCS.


It’s nice to see that Mr. Angelos still has a pulse and that he dusted off his checkbook.

But the investment is all wrong. The money should have been spent on other players.

And when buyer’s remorse sets in – and it will, you have to wonder how it will affect upcoming negotiations with Adam Jones and Manny Machado.

Remember how Pete kept his wallet hidden for a long time following the Albert Belle signing?

This Davis contract should scare you. It could cost them Adam and/or Manny down the road.

It did NOTHING to improve the Orioles.

Coincidentally the signing took place on the anniversary of another significant Orioles acquisition of another Davis – Glenn Davis.

And in the end it could be just as costly.

One Cheer about “Chris Davis Deal Will Set Orioles Back For Years

  1. Dante Rebori on said:

    Some good points made here. But I really like Chris Davis and am glad he’s staying. Let’s hope Peter Angelos doesn’t feel like this was all he needed to do. This is high stakes poker anymore and the frugal rarely win big. 2016 will be my 56th season as an Orioles fan, even though I’ve always lived in Missouri. I’m O Positive in blood type and O’s positive in my outlook on baseball.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.

Hot off the street

Give that Fan a Podcast Ep 6 – Eric Arditti
Give that Fan a Podcast Ep 6 – Eric Arditti

Barstool Sports' Eric Arditti joins this week's podcast to talk Trey Mancini, Adley Rutschman, Mo Gaba, and much more. If you're not into snakes or Breaking Bad, the O's chatter begins around the more

Give that Fan a Podcast Ep. 5 – Jake Mintz
Give that Fan a Podcast Ep. 5 – Jake Mintz

The Orioles fan half of Cespedes Family BBQ, Jake Mintz, joins me in the fifth episode of the show. We each provide a list of our top 20 favorite O's prospect names in the system, but first, we dive more

Give That Fan a Podcast Ep 4: Jason La Canfora
Give That Fan a Podcast Ep 4: Jason La Canfora

CBS Sports NFL Insider and co-host of Inside Access on 105.7 The Fan, Jason La Canfora, joins me for the fourth episode of the podcast. We dive into the reasons behind switching team allegiances, more

Give That Fan a Podcast – Episode 3: Olivia!
Give That Fan a Podcast – Episode 3: Olivia!

In Episode 03, I’m joined by Olivia Witherite, who spent 8 years working in different social media and marketing roles at MASN until she moved on to a job with The Athletic in 2019. We re-lived more

Give That Fan a Podcast – Episode 2
Give That Fan a Podcast – Episode 2

In this episode, I fly solo and talk about myself for 45 minutes. What good is a podcast if you can't get to know the host a little bit? I take you through my life as a baseball fan and an Orioles more

View More