Age-27 Rule is a Baseball Myth

Chris Davis trots around the bases.
GulfBird Sports/Craig Landefeld

For a long time, it was said that baseball players reach their prime at the age of 27. It has, of course, been debunked as a myth – there is no rule that can ever state when an individual athlete reaches his or her peak age in sports. Besides, there is the new peak age for athletes in every generation, considering the ever newer and more efficient training techniques and nutrition regimens becoming increasingly widespread. This might be the reason why the peak performance of athletes in various sports has shifted toward an older age.

In baseball, there is something called the “Age-27” rule, stating that “a hitter tends to break out in his age-27 season.” This myth was largely based on an essay by baseball analyst and statistician Bill James, where he concluded that baseball players tend to offer their teams their peak performance around the age of 27. He recommended that, if a peak period has to be assigned to players, it should be the one between the ages of 25 and 29. Ultimately, James himself abandoned his method of assessing the performance of players this way, realizing that his methods failed to take into account players whose performance was deemed below major-league performance who stopped playing.

Author J. C. Bradbury, author of “The Baseball Economist: The Real Game Exposed”, has found another method of analyzing the performance of baseball hitters and pitchers, one that seems closer to reality, taking into account many factors James seemed to overlook in his essay. His results put the peak performance for both hitters and pitchers around the age of 29 – on average, that is. When it comes to specific tasks, like hitting, pitching, walking, and such, the ages of peak performance differ. “Hitters peak in batting and slugging average at 28 while continuing to improve in their home-run hitting and walking abilities until 30 and 32, respectively,” he wrote. “Pitcher strikeout ability peaks around 24, while walk prevention peaks nine years later. Again, veteran know-how appears to be playing a role in improving performance to compensate for diminishing physical skills.”

Even the averages Bradbury found seem not to apply to some of the players still active today. Bartolo Colón, a pitcher for the Texas Rangers (MLB), is still very much active at the age of 45, well after his statistical prime. Koji Uehara, who made his MLB debut with the Orioles in 2009, is still active at the Tokyo-based professional baseball team Yomiuri Giants at the age of 43. And Ichiro Suzuki, another Japanese professional outfielder who made his MLB debut in 2001, has just signed a one-year contract with the Seattle Mariners this March – at the age of 44.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.

Hot off the street

The Payoff Pitch – Juice & Juiced Balls
The Payoff Pitch – Juice & Juiced Balls

Today on the show, I go over some of the Birds' recent roster moves, including designating Mike Wright for assignment and optioning Cedric Mullins to AAA. I also climb on my soapbox a bit about some s...read more

How About the Prospects in Bowie?
How About the Prospects in Bowie?

Yesterday, in an attempt to try to divert our eyes from the trainwreck taking place at Oriole Park at Camden Yards every night, we looked at a few of the prospects in Norfolk. I introduced that piece ...read more

What’s Up with Miguel Castro? Certainly Not His Arm…
What’s Up with Miguel Castro? Certainly Not His Arm…

Orioles reliever Miguel Castro has started the 2019 season the exact wrong way. Over 11 2/3 innings, the right-hander has given up 14 earned runs, 19 hits, three home runs, and seven walks, while stri...read more

The Warehouse Episode 31: Mullins Demoted, Wright DFA’d
The Warehouse Episode 31: Mullins Demoted, Wright DFA’d

Believe it or not, the 2019 MLB season is nearly a month old already. As is common with April baseball, there has been plenty of early-season ridiculousness. Cody Bellinger and Christian Yelich are hi...read more

Are the Prospects Doing Any Better at Least?
Are the Prospects Doing Any Better at Least?

We knew this would happen eventually, though we probably hoped it wouldn't be quite so early on in the season - the big league club is downright impossible to watch, at least without constantly grimac...read more

View More