A Farewell Letter to Matt Wieters

Dear Matt,

I’m sorry. I’m sorry that we dubbed you “Mauer with Power” and “Jesus in Cleats” before you even appeared in a Major League game. We should have let you be Matt Wieters.

You see, O’s fans were looking for anything to consider a diamond in the rough. We drafted you during the tenth season of what would become fourteen in a row of losing baseball. You tore your way through the minor leagues and, by the time you made your debut in 2009, fans saw a potential franchise cornerstone in their new catcher. We decided what your career would be before it even began.

Not many catchers can boast the offensive numbers you can. Your presence behind the plate was intimidating to opposing baserunners for many years. Your soft-spoken but confident attitude shed a positive light on a dark time in Baltimore baseball history. And when the team finally turned the corner and started winning some ballgames, maybe you were a bit overshadowed by guys like Adam Jones and Manny Machado, but I’ll be damned if you didn’t play a major role in our success.

There was that time you hit a walk-off grand slam against the Rays. Nick Markakis was on third with nobody out. All you needed was a fly ball or even a grounder through a hole in the infield. Instead, you hacked at the first pitch and sent it onto the flag court. Dating back to that magical 2012 season, it was the Orioles’ 17th consecutive win in extra innings.

Matt Wieters prepares to swing.

GulfBird Photo/Craig Landefeld

And then, on your birthday last season, you turned what looked like one of the most frustrating games of the season into an exciting victory. Matt Shoemaker had absolutely shut the Orioles’ offense down for almost eight innings. You came up in the ninth against their closer and blasted an opposite-field, three-run, game-winning homer. That’s not a bad way to celebrate.

Matt Wieters follows through on his swing as the Angels catcher watches from his crouch.

There are so many other moments that come to mind but I’m sure you remember them all. From all those runners gunned down at second base to the few times you swiped a bag of your own and left O’s fans laughing in disbelief while sarcastically calling you “Wheels Wieters.” In fact, you stole bases at a higher rate than you allowed them in your career as an Oriole.

I bet not even you saw that coming.

So I want to say thank you. Thank you for your contributions to the Baltimore Orioles organization. You may not have reached the ungodly high expectations set by many but you meant a lot to this team and your value will not be forgotten.

Good luck down at Walgreens. I won’t be cheering for your team, but I will be rooting for you. Just make sure they know that “I” comes before “E.” And when the O’s come to visit in May, as if the catcher behind the plate really matters to a team that doesn’t steal often at all, we’ll be sure to remember that it’s not in our best interest to run on you. Ever.



Matt Wieters poses with his dog and cat.

This entry was posted in Blog View, Featured by Ryan Blake. Bookmark the permalink.

About Ryan Blake

Ryan joined the Eutaw Street Report crew for the site's launch in 2013 having spent the 2012 season as a member of the Orioles' tarp crew. Before then, he had never really considered writing, but has grown to enjoy sharing his opinions and is now ESR's "Hot Take" artist. In...more

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.

Hot off the street

John Means to the Moon!
John Means to the Moon!

submitted by Josh Linn Supporting your favorite baseball team in the midst of a rebuilding phase can be a grind, especially when the team does so in the unapologetic, scorched-earth fashion the Or...read more

Give That Fan a Podcast Ep 12 – Matt Blood
Give That Fan a Podcast Ep 12 – Matt Blood

The Orioles' Director of Player Development, Matt Blood, joins this week's podcast to talk about the progress being made down on the farm. We touch on just about everything, from organizational philo...read more

Give that Fan a Podcast Ep 11 – Keith Law
Give that Fan a Podcast Ep 11 – Keith Law

The Athletic's Keith Law joins me this week to take me through the thought process that led him to ranking the much-improved Orioles farm system just 18th in baseball, much to the chagrin of many O's...read more

Awaiting Beards & Bellies
Awaiting Beards & Bellies

**Taps mic** Is this thing on? Can you hear me? Okay, good. Let’s try this. photo: Kristen Hudak It’s been a while. In looking back at the archives of my musings on this website, I reali...read more

Give that Fan a Podcast Ep. 10 – Danny & Dillon
Give that Fan a Podcast Ep. 10 – Danny & Dillon

After the holiday break turned into a life-induced hiatus, I'm back and I brought a couple friends along for this episode. You might know Dillon Atkinson and Danny Majerowicz from their days on the O'...read more

View More