What in the Name of Earl Weaver is Going On Here?

Buck Showalter and Dan Duquette at O's Fan Fest on stage.

Since the conclusion of the 2017 season, countless articles (including my own) have been penned on what the Orioles could do to be ready to compete in 2018. From Alex Cobb and Lance Lynn to Lorenzo Cain and Mike Moustakas, the thoughts and postulations over the Orioles future have been bountiful, with many of them holding a great deal of validity and intrigue.

However, with pitchers and catchers reporting to Sarasota in 2 weeks (February 13th), I’m as confused as Biff Tannen witnessing a flying Delorean as to what the Orioles are doing.

The Orioles had two options to choose from, a fork in the road if you will.


Option 1

Rebuild (or “retool” if you prefer the Dan Duquette lexicon). Facing a deficiency of pitching talent (or just pitchers in general), and the imminent departure of Manny Machado, Zach Briton & Co., this option is all about the future. The debate about who or who not to do business with is a discussion beyond the scope of this article, but the opportunity to gain an influx of minor league talent was very real.

Even if you’re trading these guys for 40 cents on the dollar, you do it. You’re still getting some value for players about to walk, and if you aren’t going for it in 2018 (see option 2), this is your path to success.


Option 2

This is the easier sell to the fans. Go for it. The Orioles have one more season with this core group of players, and, even with the temporary loss of Britton, have enough talent in the pen to have one of the best in the AL. We know the power will be present throughout the lineup, and let’s say for arguments sake you sign a couple pitchers to make the rotation look like this: Cobb, Dylan Bundy, Andrew Cashner, Kevin Gausman, Chris Tillman. I know there are detractors on these guys, but this group stands to be a MASSIVE improvement from 2017.

Coupled with the power and bullpen, add a speedy corner OF with +defensive skills, and the chance to compete is real, and all you need to do is get in the dance to have a shot. One last stand at the Alamo.



Neither option!

In what is quite possibly the most maddening offseason of my fanhood (since circa 1985), the Orioles chose neither right or left and plowed right through the median of the proverbal fork. Status quo. They bumbled the Machado trade, have made zero meaningful signings, zero contract discussions with the face of the franchise Adam Jones, and a last place team returns to camp with two starting pitchers and minus their starting catcher.

How can this be? Ownership? A lame duck GM? A lame duck manager? Lame duck players already looking forward to new deals and new teams?

As is always the case on multiple choice exams, the answer is all of the above.

The icing on this cake is the bizarre move that Buck announced at Fan Fest, moving Machado to SS. Do I think Manny can be a Gold Glove SS? Yes, maybe. Do I think moving Tim Beckham, who has had 12 total balls hit to him while playing 3B in his MLB career, is a good idea? Probably not.

But what I can say with a high degree of confidence is that this move is not what is best for the team. Manny has proven to be a Gold Glove 3B, what do the Orioles (as a TEAM) gain by moving him? Increased trade value? Nah, I don’t buy it. Smells more like rewarding a tantrum to me. Like I said, this offseason has been really confusing.

I’m truly at a loss, and I cannot explain the direction or decisions (lack thereof) that have been made this offseason.

What does this mean for 2018? Well, it means cheap seats and protective netting for all!

4 Cheers on “What in the Name of Earl Weaver is Going On Here?

  1. avatarGary stem on said:

    Zach Davies are Miranda we do not know how to evaluate talent the last time we really had a pitcher from our minors was Mike mussna I would trade Manny in a heart beat he will be playing for the Yankees and everyone knows it, our owner and GM would screw up a wet dream. I have been folliowing the Orioles since all Bunbury and rich coggins

  2. avatarGerald B. on said:

    Bumbling idiots. And they want me to renew my season tickets. Sounds like I’ll be selling mine to Yankee and Red Sox fans.

  3. avatarFelix on said:

    This has been the most succinct evaluation would have taken place in the offseason. I commend you. After reading the masn blogs it’s refreshing to hear some honesty.

  4. avatarMike on said:

    Painful to watch. Pitching has to be priority one but I think the Jimenez nightmare has scared off management from paying for pitchers. Let’s get it in gear, O’s!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.

Hot off the street

Series Preview: Orioles (35-84) vs Mets (50-66)
Series Preview: Orioles (35-84) vs Mets (50-66)

After getting swept by the Red Sox over the weekend, the Orioles will look to wrap up the home stand on a high note with a two-game mini series against the Mets. The Orioles (35-84) will also be lo...read more

O’s Promote Cedric Mullins, DFA Danny Valencia
O’s Promote Cedric Mullins, DFA Danny Valencia

The move that many Orioles fans have been pining for for at least a month here in this lost season was finally made a reality today, as the Orioles announced that they have promoted Cedric Mullins fro...read more

Series Preview: Orioles (35-80) vs Red Sox (81-35)
Series Preview: Orioles (35-80) vs Red Sox (81-35)

The Orioles are back at Camden Yards for the first time since July 29 to begin a four-game series against the surging Boston Red Sox. The Orioles (35-80) finished their recent road trip at 3-6, and t...read more

Prospect Profile: Rogers Making Great First Impression
Prospect Profile: Rogers Making Great First Impression

A few days after the Zach Britton deal, I wrote that Cody Carroll would likely be the first of the three players acquired to reach the big leagues - even though Dillon Tate was widely viewed as the be...read more

Thursday Thoughts: With Little to Talk About, Fans Focus on Mullins
Thursday Thoughts: With Little to Talk About, Fans Focus on Mullins

This is a weekly column that dives into some random thoughts about the Orioles/MLB. I used to do eight as a nod to Cal Ripken Jr. As of last year, I cut it down to four or five, so consider it the Ear...read more

View More