Thursday Thoughts: When It’s Not Just About Ryan Flaherty

Brady Anderson and Dan Duquette talk with a microphone.
Mitch Stringer/PressBox

This is a weekly column that usually dives into some random thoughts about the Orioles/MLB. This week, I’m keeping things a bit more focused, as one issue in particular has drawn my ire. – A.S.

The Orioles continue to be one of the most dysfunctional organizations in baseball, perhaps in all of sports. This isn’t breaking news to anyone who has paid the least bit of attention. But revelations last week from The Baltimore Sun’s Eduardo Encina continued to paint a picture of ineptitude from within the franchise.

Look – the 2018 season is still four weeks away – I’m certainly not trying to throw dirt on a grave before the casket has been lowered. But the Orioles continue to dance around transparency and it makes fans question the direction of the organization. Encina’s blog reported that the Orioles couldn’t get “club-wide approval” to match a contract offer to retain Ryan Flaherty as the team’s utility infielder. This term “club-wide approval” caused my stomach to churn and my eyes to roll at the same time. It was quite a scene when I first read it. Then I realized it was something I shouldn’t be too surprised to read at all.

Ryan Flaherty stretches and watches.

GulfBird Photo/Craig Landefeld

No one really truly knows what “club-wide approval” means. That’s because no one really knows who’s calling the shots inside The Warehouse. There’s a widespread belief that Dan Duquette, the team’s Executive Vice President of Baseball Operations, has built this team. There’s also an understanding that he’s done so with great help and input from the manager of the team, Buck Showalter.

Yet, everyone knows that the two don’t see eye to eye. There has always been an unspoken tension between the two, and it’s been widely reported, mostly in the national media. There’s also Brady Anderson, the team’s former outfielder who currently serves as Vice President of Baseball Operations. That’s a title that’s very similar to that of Duquette’s. Many believe Duquette is the team’s “general manager,” and in practical terms, that’s exactly what he is. But the O’s haven’t used that title to describe his position, and I merely point that out to highlight just how similar the title is to Anderson’s.

When Duquette explained earlier this winter the team’s reason for failing to make a presentation to now Angels phenom Shohei Ohtani by saying “because philosophically we don’t participate on the posting part of it,” it gave me a similar feeling as the “club-wide approval” line did. No one really knows what “philosophically we don’t participate” means. That’s because the organization isn’t transparent about its ideas, mindset or direction. It’s as if the team has used the “invisibility cloak” from the “Harry Potter” series to mask exactly what is going on.

At the top of the food chain within The Warehouse, of course, is the team’s owner Peter Angelos. The 88-year-old is coming up on 25 years having been the majority owner of the Orioles, and the public probably knows about as much about him and his mindset now as it did in 1993. Does “club-wide approval” mean Angelos wouldn’t sign-off on giving a utility infielder who had been with the team for six years a new deal to stick around for a couple million bucks? While ownership approval would be expected for a big contract, would it really be necessary in the case of a deal for Flaherty?

Is “philosophically we don’t participate” a mantra that comes from Angelos, or is that a Duquette musing? There’s been no shortage of vitriol hurled at ownership over the past two decades-plus, but no one really knows where the decisions are coming from. There is plenty of speculation to that end, but no clear cut answers.

I’m not sitting here trying to be the lone guy to go to bat for Ryan Flaherty. The Orioles will survive without the services of Flaherty. But wouldn’t you feel more comfortable with Flaherty having to play a few games than any of the guys currently vying for the spot vacated by the utility man?

In this strange triangle of leadership within the Orioles, there are also many other tentacles that have yet to be explained or revealed. There is an analytics department and scouting department that also have a say in which players are signed, retained and traded.

The lack of transparency is perhaps what frustrates the fanbase more than anything. If everyone knew who to point the finger toward, it would be easy. For now, that person has to be Duquette, being that he is at the top of the decision-making food chain.

Flaherty, frankly, is the least of the question marks when it comes to front office decisions. The others are well-publicized. Manny Machado, Adam Jones and Zach Britton are all in walk years. Jonathan Schoop still does not have a long-term deal. The Orioles are piecing together a rotation with silly string and chewing gum.

Not to mention, Duquette and Showalter are also sitting on expiring contracts. Some might say the Orioles have a big season ahead and need to make many decisions before August. Others, like myself, would say and even fear that it’s too late. This mess is already starting to boil over.

It’s ironic that a player as simultaneously minor and polarizing as Ryan Flaherty has been the one to bring these issues – and the emotions from fans that go along with them – to the surface once again.

5 Cheers on “Thursday Thoughts: When It’s Not Just About Ryan Flaherty

  1. avatarBobby D on said:

    Not sure who is in low gear moving forward but Lynn and Cobb are still available. Other players can bill filled in but our rotation is not adiquate with other AL East clubs. Injuries can occur quickly and if any of our four in the rotation go down it would be devastating. Cobb and Lynn should except a 3/4 year deal now please don’t stand pat hoping that our youth will handle the load. I’m a 45 yr Oriole fan and i’ve seen this movie over and over.

  2. avatarTwoEdgedSword on said:

    I am so sick of this notion that the Orioles are a “dysfunctional franchise” because they didn’t sign Ryan Flaherty. Come on! You’re the same guys who dished on Flaherty every single game even before you finished your first beer. Let let Flaherty go – that’s pretty much it. They didn’t “disrespect” him. Ryan Flaherty is making pretty darned good money to play baseball for the Phillies now.

    As much as I am unhappy with the Orioles for not making better roster moves, I’m less so with the focus on … what? Ryan Flaherty? It’s a story for hype’s sake, sold to the angry fan types just as much as the media sells “Chris Tillman is comeback player of the year”. Just stop.

    • Derek ArnoldDerek Arnold on said:

      I’d say that you’re missing the forest for the trees here. It’s not about Flaherty, in particular, he’s just the avatar for the dysfunction in this particular interest. What does CLUB-WIDE approval mean? Why do they need that for a utility infielder? They’re not dysfunctional because they didn’t sign Ryan Flaherty, they didn’t sign Ryan Flaherty because they’re dysfunctional.

      • avatarRyan on said:

        Exactly, did this cat even read the article? The Orioles front office is a joke. The author didn’t even get a chance to touch on the fact that they don’t participate in the international market. Which is is MIND BLOWING to me. For the life of me I can’t understand it. Also, why do we hate high OBP guys so much?

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.

Hot off the street

Friday’s O’s Links: Dylan Bundy to Make First Opening Day Start
Friday’s O’s Links: Dylan Bundy to Make First Opening Day Start

The snow has already completely cleared from the ground in most parts of Baltimore, a fitting sight as we sit now less than a week from Opening Day. Now let's push that mercury a bit further up, eh more

Thursday Thoughts: Prediction Time
Thursday Thoughts: Prediction Time

This is a weekly column that dives into some random thoughts about the Orioles/MLB. I used to do eight as a nod to Cal Ripken Jr. As of last year, I cut it down to four or five, so consider it the more

Orioles Starting Rotation Comes Into Focus
Orioles Starting Rotation Comes Into Focus

Over the last week or so, this column has been dedicated to answering some of the roster questions the Orioles still have as Opening Day draws near. Having already discussed the outfield and the more

Orioles Get their Man in Alex Cobb
Orioles Get their Man in Alex Cobb

In this space three weeks ago, I condemned the Orioles for their lack of moves to make the team a legitimate contender entering 2018. I criticized the outfield situation, namely the signing of Colby more

Wednesday’s O’s Links: Hi, Alex!
Wednesday’s O’s Links: Hi, Alex!

While we were all scrambling to stock up on our bread, milk, and toilet paper yesterday evening, the Orioles were finalizing discussions with Alex Cobb to bring the free agent pitcher to Baltimore. more

View More