KNEE-JERK REACTIONS: Orioles, Trumbo Agree on Three-Year Deal

Mark Trumbo watches after swinging.
GulfBird Photo/Craig Landefeld

Per multiple reports, the Orioles and slugger Mark Trumbo have agreed on a new three-year contract.

ESR staff react to the news here:

Derek Arnold

While I’m not overly excited about having Trumbo back, at three years and just $37 million, it’s hard to complain about the deal. The Birds will hope that they get first-half Mark back, and not the guy who fell apart in the second half.

It’s not reasonable to expect 47 home runs and an .850 OPS again, but if Trumbo puts up numbers that are in line with those of his career (34 HR, .776 OPS), O’s fans will be satisfied.

There are plenty who would have rather seen the O’s spend some money on a pitcher, but what pitcher are you going to get for that kind of deal?

Here’s to another three years of majestic TRUMBOMBS at the Yard!

Phil Backert

The Orioles once again get their player at their price, a strategy that has worked well for them in the Duquette era. Trumbo can now DH against right-handers and possibly play right field against lefties with Trey Mancini sliding in at DH. I still can’t get over how cheap Trumbo signed for. If the numbers shake out correctly, Ubaldo Jimenez could earn more this season than Trumbo. Wild.

Joe Polek

This is a good deal for the Orioles. Now that they have a couple corner outfielders to use and rotate, Trumbo can be the everyday DH. And keeping him in this lineup was crucial. The Orioles are set up to be better in 2017 than they were in 2016 without upgrading pitching.

Ryan Blake

All offseason, I’ve been part of the “let him walk” camp. Trumbo, last season, posted the lowest fWAR among single-season home run leaders in the live ball era. That essentially means he was a “HR or Bust” type of player with bad defense. For that reason, and as a fan of a team that’s has lived and died by the home run for several years now, I had no interest in bringing him back.

Now, as the Orioles have their outfield spoken for and will seemingly use Trumbo almost exclusively as a designated hitter, I’m happy with this deal, especially at such a low price. His value will increase since he probably won’t be playing much outfield. As long as the power numbers don’t dwindle, he’ll be a valuable asset to the team.

Andrew Stetka

The Orioles went ahead and did the one thing I hoped they wouldn’t do this offseason and gave Mark Trumbo a multi-year deal. Whether they were hypnotized by his career season and home run swing or just decided to give out their money to a guy who wore the same uniform last year, it’s a bad deal.

Last year aside, Trumbo is not a very good baseball player. He’s a power hitter who strikes out a lot and plays awful defense. Now they are locked into paying him for another three years. Look, getting Trumbo for Steve Clevenger in retrospect was a great deal. I’m not going to deny that. But it’s also important to remember that it only took Steve Clevenger to get Trumbo (and C.J. Riefenhauser).

Attaching yourself to him like this isn’t a good idea. It’s not like they are paying massive dollars for him, but I think there is a big misconception about the type of player Trumbo really is because of the season he had last year. The only saving grace in this deal is that it’s for three years, and not four. Also, the O’s didn’t bid against themselves after pulling their previous offer. They got him at a (very) small discount to what the initial offer was reported at.

The Birds still don’t have a very good defensive outfielder on their roster (aside from Adam Jones). Joey Rickard will be talked up, but who knows if he’s even in line to make the roster at this point. There are more cooks in the kitchen.

Jonathan French

I’m not a fan of this deal for a few reasons. The first is that is Trumbo doesn’t solve any current needs for the Orioles as they needed to drastically improve their hitting against LHP and outfield defense. Trumbo, although he has a career wRC+ of 113 against LHP, only had a wRC+ of 54 against them last season so there’s reasonable doubt if he’ll be as effective against them as he has been in the past. Trumbo’s defense also is questionable because of his -9 DRS in RF last season. With a likely platoon of him with Seth Smith in RF, however, the Orioles may be able to mitigate that some by having Trumbo only play the field against LHP instead of the opposite last season. Like Kim though, he may need a defensive replacement in the later innings, so this makes Rule 5 pick Aneury Tavarez more likely to stick on the roster as Joey Rickard will already likely be playing LF.

The contract terms are reasonable, but the Orioles could have had a better overall hitter in Chris Carter against LHP for less or they could have kept Trey Mancini, who will now have a harder time sticking on the 25-man roster as only a platoon DH against LHP. Pedro Alvarez would have been a better fit against RHP at DH for less which is where Trumbo will see most of his PAs. The Orioles also lose the compensation pick that they would have received had another team signed Trumbo before June which was highly likely. For a team that desperately needs top quality talent in its minors, giving up that draft pick is not without consequences.

When you look at all of that, this may have played out like the Chris Davis saga did last season, and it will certainly be spun that way. The Orioles waited around long enough get their slugger that nobody else really wanted for the price they were willing to pay. This time though, I think Trumbo was the wrong target.

Joe Serpico

It has been rumored for some time now that the Orioles and Mark Trumbo were inching to a deal. It was a deal that made sense for everyone.

Trumbo does not get the huge pay day that he was expecting after his career year, but gets to keep playing in the ballpark where he hit 25 home runs. While it’s unlikely he posts the same numbers, the O’s have a legitimate designated hitter for the next few years.

For Baltimore, keeping the reigning home run leader for $37.5 million over three years after Jose Bautista suckered the the Blue Jays for $18 million this season is a bargain. This is also a deal that does not hamper them when the discussions start for Zach Britton and Manny Machado. It’s good to see the Orioles keeping their own in recent years.

We’ll add more knee-jerk reactions as they roll in…

This entry was posted in Blog View, Featured by ESR Staff. Bookmark the permalink.

About ESR Staff

ESR Staff
Occasionally, the entire Eutaw Street Report staff will contribute to a post. These are usually instant reactions to news, signings, big games, etc. It's like sitting at the bar and hearing the news/watching the game with us!...more

One Cheer about “KNEE-JERK REACTIONS: Orioles, Trumbo Agree on Three-Year Deal

  1. avatarLou D. on said:

    So now the Orioles have a hitter (if you combine Davis and Trumbo’s outs) that could go 0 for 450 with 450 strikeouts. Imagine a major league hitter doing that. That’s a lot of men left on base. Doesn’t help their offense.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.

Hot off the street

Manny Machado or Jonathan Schoop?
Manny Machado or Jonathan Schoop?

The hot stove has been heating up the past couple of weeks with some minor O’s chatter about the likes of Jason Vargas, Tyler Chatwood and Andrew Cashner. Those acquisitions would do very little to ...read more

Do Andrew Cashner and/or Eduardo Nunez Excite You?
Do Andrew Cashner and/or Eduardo Nunez Excite You?

We're into mid-November now, and after one of the most exciting World Series in memory (maybe ever), we've been without baseball for what feels like eons. However, the Hot Stove season has yet to real...read more

Trey Mancini Named Rookie of the Year Finalist
Trey Mancini Named Rookie of the Year Finalist

O's rookie Trey Mancini got some good news tonight, as he was named a finalist for the BBWAA Rookie of the Year award. https://twitter.com/Orioles/status/927672846381387777 Mancini was a revelat...read more

In Addition to Pitching, O’s Must Address OBP Woes
In Addition to Pitching, O’s Must Address OBP Woes

https://twitter.com/idresurgence/status/679413880091762690?lang=en The Orioles' ongoing goal of finding a high-On Base Percentage corner outfielder continues as we officially enter the 2017-2018 of...read more

This Family Dressed as the Crab Shuffle for Halloween
This Family Dressed as the Crab Shuffle for Halloween

This family of O's fans has one of the most creative costumes I've ever seen come out of Birdland - they dressed as the Oriole Park at Camden Yards favorite, "The Crab Shuffle." Watch them go: h...read more

View More