AL East Positional Rankings – Shortstop

J.J. Hardy prepares to defend.
Craig Landefeld/GulfBird Photo

In part five of my positional rankings, I round out the infield by previewing the shortstops in the American League East. As is always the case, this list is subject to change should an injury occur, or should the incumbent player(s) be unseated.

Other Positions:

First Base
Second Base
Third Base

The position of shortstop has always been a strong one in the AL East. From Cal Ripken, Jr., Nomar Garciaparra, and Derek Jeter in the 80s, 90s, and early 2000s to Xander Bogaerts, Troy Tulowitzki, and J.J. Hardy today, there have been numerous All-Star appearances, world championships, and MVP-caliber seasons.

One of the most polarizing positions in baseball, a team’s shortstop is the captain of the infield. But who, in 2017, is the best of the best at the shortstop position in the AL East? Ask, and ye shall receive.



1. Xander Bogaerts – Boston Red Sox

2016: .294/.356/.446, 21 HR, 89 RBI

The choice here was obvious. Bogaerts is the premier shortstop in the American League East, and is coming off back-to-back seasons in which he has averaged 194 H, 14 HR, 85 RBI, 100 R, and a .356 OBP. He has won the AL Silver Slugger for the shortstop position each of the last two seasons, and in 2016 made his first All-Star appearance, earning the starting nod in the process.

At the age of 24, Bogaerts is the youngest shortstop in the division and should only get better as his career progresses, which is good news for the Red Sox, and bad news for the rest of the division.

2. Troy Tulowitzki – Toronto Blue Jays

2016: .254/.318/.443, 24 HR, 79 RBI

It wasn’t that long ago that Tulowitzki could have been considered the best shortstop in the game, not just within the division. The 2007 runner up for National League Rookie of the Year, Tulo has made six All-Star teams while winning two Gold Gloves and two Silver Slugger awards. His 162-game average is Hall of Fame worthy, averaging 29 HR and 100 RBI to go along with a .292 career average.

The problem is, Tulo has never played 162 games in a season. In fact, he has only played 140+ games in a season three times in his 11-year career. Add to that the fact that his .254 BA in 2016 was the lowest of his career, and it’s not hard to see why he has slipped out of the top spot.

But the fact remains, when healthy, Troy Tulowitzki is as dangerous and well-rounded a shortstop as there is in the game, and with the lineup hitting around him, he could rebound very nicely in 2017.

3. Didi Gregorius – New York Yankees

2016: .276/.304/.447, 20 HR, 70 RBI

Much like his teammate Starlin Castro, Didi Gregorious notched his first 20-homer season in 2016, providing punch to the Yankees lineup from an unexpected source. The thing to like most about Gregorius is that he can be counted on to be in the lineup and on the field just about every night, averaging 154 games in his two seasons in New York. His range at shortstop is fantastic as he gets to balls that most other shortstops do not, and his consistency is a plus; just look at his nearly identical home and road splits.

At just 27-years-old, his stock appears to be on the rise. The Yankees have themselves a very nice player in Gregorius, and his middle-of-the-pack ranking could improve with a similar season in 2017.

4. J.J. Hardy – Baltimore Orioles

2016: .269/.309/.407, 9 HR, 48 RBI

In his first three seasons in Baltimore, Hardy rediscovered his All-Star form from his days in Milwaukee, averaging 26 HR and 75 RBI per year. But then Hardy’s back started flaring up, sapping the power out of his swing, and he has averaged just nine HR and 46 RBI over the last three years.

That said, Hardy is a veteran presence for the Orioles, and he catches everything hit to him.  His glove is fundamentally sound, but never flashy, though his arm is average at best these days. At 34-years-old, Hardy is a shell of the player he once was, and his time in Baltimore is most likely coming to an end after 2017.

5. Matt Duffy – Tampa Bay Rays

2016: .258/.310/.357, 5 HR, 28 RBI

Duffy burst onto the scene in 2015, slashing .295/.334/.428 with 12 HR and 77 RBI, while also going 12-12 in SB on his way to a runner-up finish in the NL Rookie of the Year voting. However, lingering Achilles pain caused a down-tick in his production in 2016, ultimately leading to season-ending surgery in early September. Couple that with the fact that Duffy, exclusively a third basemen before being traded to Tampa Bay, is still learning how to play shortstop at the Major League level, and it’s not so hard to justify the low ranking.

If Duffy returns to his rookie form, he will surely move up this list. But until then, much like the team he plays for, he’s last in the division.


1. Brad Miller – Tampa Bay Rays*

2016: .243/.304/.382, 30 HR, 81 RBI

2. Brock Holt – Boston Red Sox

2016: .255/.322/.383, 7 HR, 34 RBI

3. Darwin Barney – Toronto Blue Jays

2016: .269/.322/.373, 4 HR, 19 RBI

4. Ronald Torreyes – New York Yankees

2016: .258/.305/.374, 1 HR, 12 RBI

5. Ryan Flaherty – Baltimore Orioles

2016: .217/.291/.318, 3 HR, 15 RBI

*Team’s second baseman

That does it for the shortstops in the AL East. As always, this list is up for debate, and is just one man’s opinion, nothing more. Up next, I move to the outfield, ranking the left fielders within the division.

This entry was posted in Blog View, Featured by Paul Valle. Bookmark the permalink.

About Paul Valle

Paul Valle
Paul Valle is a Baltimore native who has always had a passion for baseball. But his passion goes beyond the average spectator. Paul has been studying baseball--specifically the Orioles--since his youth. He not only appreciates the on field play, but the strategy and statistics behind it. Paul obtained a Bachelor...more

2 Cheers on “AL East Positional Rankings – Shortstop

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.

Hot off the street

Friday’s O’s Links: Dylan Bundy to Make First Opening Day Start
Friday’s O’s Links: Dylan Bundy to Make First Opening Day Start

The snow has already completely cleared from the ground in most parts of Baltimore, a fitting sight as we sit now less than a week from Opening Day. Now let's push that mercury a bit further up, eh more

Thursday Thoughts: Prediction Time
Thursday Thoughts: Prediction Time

This is a weekly column that dives into some random thoughts about the Orioles/MLB. I used to do eight as a nod to Cal Ripken Jr. As of last year, I cut it down to four or five, so consider it the more

Orioles Starting Rotation Comes Into Focus
Orioles Starting Rotation Comes Into Focus

Over the last week or so, this column has been dedicated to answering some of the roster questions the Orioles still have as Opening Day draws near. Having already discussed the outfield and the more

Orioles Get their Man in Alex Cobb
Orioles Get their Man in Alex Cobb

In this space three weeks ago, I condemned the Orioles for their lack of moves to make the team a legitimate contender entering 2018. I criticized the outfield situation, namely the signing of Colby more

Wednesday’s O’s Links: Hi, Alex!
Wednesday’s O’s Links: Hi, Alex!

While we were all scrambling to stock up on our bread, milk, and toilet paper yesterday evening, the Orioles were finalizing discussions with Alex Cobb to bring the free agent pitcher to Baltimore. more

View More